Immigrant Women Teach Us All Are Sacred: On Rey M. Rodríguez’s Todos Somos Sagrados / All Are Sacred
By José Enrique Medina
There is a moment in “Restos de Amor / Remnants of Love” when a woman in a church pew complains about the smell of the homeless men sleeping on the floor, and her comadre quietly corrects her: that smell, she says, is the remnants of love. It is one of the finest moments in Rey M. Rodríguez’s debut collection—the book’s moral argument compressed into a single exchange between two women who will never be famous, in a church most people will never visit, in a neighborhood most people drive past without stopping.
Todos Somos Sagrados / All Are Sacred is a documentary poetry project, a community chronicle, and a poetic testimonio rooted in the 40-year history of Proyecto Pastoral at Dolores Mission in Boyle Heights. Rodríguez spent three decades on its board. This is not a poet observing a community from a careful distance. This is someone who was in the room, at the table, in the kitchen, for all of it—and that proximity shows on every page.
Again and again, the collection insists that love arrives wearing work clothes. It cooks frijoles after a twelve-hour shift. It escorts children home through gang territory. It finds room for one more cot on a church floor. The women whose names recur throughout (Lupe, Paula, Margarita, Yolanda, Esperanza, Rita, Rosa, Sofía) are not symbols. They are people, named with the precision that is its own form of love. More importantly, they are the ones doing the work. Organizing. Cooking. Protecting. Building. One of the collection's recurring observations is that community labor often falls to women, while many of the men drift away, disappear, or fail to act when action is required. Again and again, these women step forward when the men around them will not. The book has a word for that refusal: cobardía. Cowardice.
The bilingual structure, with every poem in Spanish facing its English translation, does more than honor the community’s language. It enacts the book’s central argument: that seeing each other whole requires meeting each other in the language we actually live in. The lines that remain untranslated—“Es nuestro compromiso,” “Es lo que haría Jesús”—function as holy ground, held in the original because some things are only true in the tongue they were first spoken.
“¿Son Todos Sagrados? / Are All Sacred?” is the collection’s philosophical center. Through its repeated moral binary of what follows if all people are sacred, what follows if none are, the poem asks a question larger than Boyle Heights: what kind of society do we become when we decide some lives matter less than others? It moves across homelessness, immigration, incarceration, environmental justice, and healthcare without losing the specificity that gives it weight. It reads like a manifesto that earned its conclusions.
“Hay un Jardín Creciendo en Boyle Heights / There is a Garden Growing in Boyle Heights” transforms a neighborhood into a living garden populated not by flowers but by gardeners, electricians, carpenters, childcare workers, and laborers—and gang members quietly renamed as simply children. The extended metaphor never strains because Rodríguez keeps returning it to earth.
“Huele a Patas” is the collection’s most sensory poem and one of its most structurally satisfying. Fifty homeless men sleep on the church floor. Everyone complains about the smell. Incense is burned, potpourri spread, carpet cleaner applied, the vacuum run over and over again. Then the priests decide to preach the smell itself, to ask the congregation directly what the church smells like. Then one old woman holding a wooden rosary whispers her answer. Not feet. Roses. It is not a punchline. It is a defiance.
“Cinco Cosas / Five Things” reveals a side of the collection that might be missed on a first read: its humor. The poem moves through social justice, joy, reciprocity, and dignity before landing on a joke about a Franciscan, a Dominican, and a Jesuit navigating a blackout together. That Rodríguez can hold grief, political outrage, and a clerical punchline in the same poem without any of it collapsing is a testament to how deeply he trusts the community he’s writing about. Resilience includes laughter. The book knows this.
“El Sofá” follows a donated couch through the eyes of four-year-old Maribel, for whom a plain sofa in a plain house is a mansion, a place to dream, everything. The adult narrator sees a used piece of furniture. The child sees a world. The gap between those two perceptions carries all the weight the poem needs.
“Socorro,” a prose poem about a woman found dead under the Fourth Street Bridge, is the collection’s most politically unresolved piece and its most courageous. Rodríguez gives us municipal language—“According to the L.A. Police, the female body was discovered around 9:50 p.m.”—alongside grief, alongside rage, alongside the paralysis of bearing witness to a city that forgets to feel. It doesn’t offer consolation. It implicates everyone in the stillness.
Father Gregory Boyle writes in his preface that the work of Proyecto Pastoral is an act of “inclusion, non-violence, unconditional loving, kindness, and compassionate acceptance.” Rodríguez’s poems are the proof of that claim made visible—not argued for, but shown, in kitchens and church floors and the eyes of a four-year-old girl seeing a sofa for the first time.
Rodríguez understands that history is usually written about the powerful. His poems reverse that instinct. They remember the women who cooked the meals, organized the meetings, opened the doors, walked children home, and built institutions sturdy enough to outlast them. The collection’s deepest achievement is not simply that it asks whether all people are sacred. It remembers the immigrant women who spent forty years living as if the answer were yes.
Published in World Literature Today
Meet the Critic
José Enrique Medina is a queer Chicano poet, playwright, novelist, and literary critic. His debut poetry collection, Only the Dead Let Me Talk This Much, won the 2026 Lambda Literary J. Michael Samuel Prize. His chapbook Haunt Me won the 2025 Rattle Chapbook Prize. His work has appeared in USA Today Hispanic Living Magazine, Los Angeles Review, Best Microfiction 2019, and elsewhere. A PEN America Emerging Voices Fellow, he is the founder of the Chickens & Poetry Residency for Writers. Connect with him on Instagram @MedinaWrites or at MedinaWrites.com.





























