Assessing YA lit
La Bloga's contributors cover many
genres, especially children's lit, Chicano nonfiction, memoirs, detective and
crime, chicalit, works in Spanish, sci-fi, magic realism and poetry. The Young
Adult genre has been covered, though nowhere as extensively as its share of the
market.
Last year sales in
young adult were up 13%, and up
117% in e-books, more than twice the digital growth in adult
markets. Reports indicate that young adult fiction yielded much bigger advances
to authors.
It's obviously an important
genre, given its influence on the younger generation. Also, in a La Bloga series last
year, "Spic vs spec - 1. Chicanos/latinos & sci-fi lit", I referenced how classic, American SciFi helped
produce the scientists and engineers responsible for the U.S. space program.
For these and other reasons,
I've decided to shift my posts to YA lit, especially to the speculative novels
of SciFi, fantasy and magic realism. I will focus on books pertinent to
Chicano, latino et al youth, but not exclude others.
I'm not a teenager, nor certain
if I ever was a "regular" one, either. And from my limited
understanding of YA, I won't be reviewing books, so much as assessing them for the
messages they give to the young. In
the process, I'll refer readers to other, regular reviews.
Morals, ethics, principles,
beliefs--all reviewers inject some or much of this into their reviews. I
propose to bring mine out front, bring them to bear on specific stories and
come out on the other end with "what's the message," if you will.
Being subjective means my
opinion can't be taken as THE word about YA books. My intention isn't to attempt to
develop a Must-Read or Never-Let-Your-Kid-Read lists. Kids read what they want
to, not what their parents wish they would, anyway.
I can already hear Latin@
author cringing, hoping I don't zero in on their work. I know how my gente is
and don't necessarily expect my assessments will be met with open brazos. For
that reason, I'm going to test my methods on non-brown authors and books first.
That won't get me off the hook, but it will give you an idea of the basis for the
appraisals. I'd welcome a better term than that one or assessments.
In the end, I hope to generate
dialogue, not only among Chicano et al authors, about the nature of YA
authorship in these times. I begin.
YA a different way 1
Halo - The Flood (2003) by NYT bestselling author William C. Dietz who's published over
forty novels. On his website, Dietz doesn't list any more than he's an American
author. Halo is one of the most popular war video games, so boys particularly
may pick up one of novels in the series. The book was a Publishers Weekly Top Ten paperback bestseller, listed as SciFi
genre, not YA. It's written as an "adult" book, but appeals to youth
because of its game connection. (Here's reviews about it by gamesters. Go here for an Amazon synopsis.)
If you're into
war, kill, death, weapons, soldiers, alien enemies and earthling heroes, that's in the novel. If
you're not, pick up something else. From the first chapter, the novel takes you
in and through to the end of the Halo videogame.
- Tired or wounded soldiers can usually fix themselves with drugs, ganas or inspiring leaders, and keep on fighting.
- There are no cowards on "our side," the earthlings'.
- Our heroes always come up with more weapons or ammo and only run out of anything for brief periods.
- Lack of sleep, rest or food never stops "our side" for long.
- There are few female good-guy soldiers.
- Shotguns aren't just legal in war, they're very good to use.
- The enemy is stupid and are inferior fighters, no matter their technology.
- It is quick and easy to kill hundreds of the enemy, no matter how many come at you or how they're armed.
- The enemy doesn't take prisoners, except for special ones they need to torture for info, collaborate against their people, or Spartan, who is basically Super Soldier, their most deadly and seemingly invincible enemy.
- The good guys, especially the hero Spartan, can go for hundreds of pages, killing hundreds of the enemy and suffer no regrets, PTSD or negative changes to their personalities.
- In war, there is no collateral damage, since there are no civilians in the story.
- The war on the alien threat is never-ending.
I plowed through this book and
about two thirds of the way through, my mule had difficulty traversing the mud
of death, body parts and blood. After a few thousand kills, I wondered about
the mind of a reader still interested, entertained and avid to turn the page.
From what I've read, violent
games don't breed school shooters. On the other hand, it's conceivable such
games and a novel like this do breed something. I won't make this assessment
any more subjective by saying what I think that is.
This completes YA A Different
Way 1. I am very interested to know what La Bloga readers and contributors feel
about this post. Should they include more? Should I push the envelope of criticism? Qué más?
Next time, I'll up the stakes
by assessing the messages of non-Chicano author Paolo Bacigalupi, bestselling
author of The Windup Girls--an
incredible novel. I'll consider instead his two YA SciFi bestsellers, Shipbreakers and Drowned Cities. I'll examine his novels in the context of his
words, "Give up on the adults!."
2 to 1 Matching Fundraising
Campaign - Only 1 day left!
"Museo's long-term benefactor, Irving Tragen, has offered a matching grant
that will make it possible to own our building in the Art District on Santa Fe
that we have occupied since 1991. Mr. Tragen has offered $50,000 if we
meet a goal of $25,000 by June 30, 2013. Through many Museo friends and
100% of our board contributing, we have raised $18,000.
"Please give today to support the only Latin American museum in Colorado,
which serves 11,000 students and 20,000 visitors each year!
"Thank you for your generosity!"
Keystone XL Pipeline - not good
news
From Obama's Climate Change
statement:
"I know there's been, for
example, a lot of controversy surrounding the proposal to build a pipeline -
the Keystone pipeline, that would carry oil from Canadian tar sands down to
refineries in the Gulf. The State Department is going through the final stages
of evaluating the proposal. That's how it's always been done. But I do
want to be clear. Allowing the Keystone pipeline to be built requires a finding
that doing so would be in our nation's interest. And our national interest
will be served only if this project does not significantly exacerbate the
problem of carbon pollution. The net effects of the pipeline's impact on
our climate will be absolutely critical to determining whether this project is
allowed to go forward. It's relevant."
It's relevant, as he says, but he may approve the pipeline. The reason is, the wording "significantly exacerbate." The
State Dept.'s has already certified that the pipeline won't "significantly
exacerbate the problem of carbon pollution." The EPA is not in agreement. Pipelines
leak, energy companies lie about safety and compliance, their
compliance with regulations. Those are the inescapable facts about
pipelines, especially
oil pipelines, especially
tar-sands oil pipelines, especially tar-sands oil will poison the
atmosphere and further char-broil the planet. The Oglalla Aquifer will be
affected by the filthiest fossil-fuel ever. Obama may take a dive on this summer.
You can read more here.
Here you can do something about it in your area, this
summer.
Es todo, hoy,
RudyG
aka Rudy Ch. Garcia, author of The Closet of Discarded Dreams, awarded Honorable Mention at the 2013 International Latino Book Awards, Fantasy/SciFi category
2 comments:
so, what about the mind of the reader drinking in this blood and guts stuff? as a high schooler i consumed war lit, naked and the dead, red badge of courage, battle cry and exodus, and knew all the service songs from vinyl. did that make me a good soldier who followed orders by day, did my own thing by night?
Sedano, I believe you answered your own question.
Besides, I only intend to do lit criticism, not psych evals.
RudyG
Post a Comment